Prevailing Wage Estimating for MEP Contractors: Davis-Bacon vs Open Shop

The same set of drawings can produce two very different bids depending on one line in the specifications: whether the job is prevailing wage. On public work, labor rates are set by a wage determination, not by what you normally pay your crews. Prevailing wage estimating means building your labor cost from those required rates, adding the fringe benefits and paperwork that come with them, and knowing how the result compares with your usual open shop numbers.

This guide explains what changes in an MEP estimate when a project is prevailing wage, and the mistakes that cost contractors money on public bids.

What is prevailing wage?

Prevailing wage is the minimum hourly pay, plus fringe benefits, that contractors must pay workers on certain publicly funded projects. On federal and federally assisted construction, the rates come from the Davis-Bacon Act wage determinations published on SAM.gov. Many states and some cities have their own prevailing wage laws for state and local projects, with their own rate tables and rules. The project specifications tell you which determination applies.

Prevailing wage vs open shop: what changes in the estimate

  • Hourly rates: on an open shop job you use your own internal labor rates. On a prevailing wage job, the base rate for each worker classification is set by the wage determination for that county and type of construction.
  • Fringe benefits: prevailing wage rates include a fringe amount that must be paid either as benefits or as cash. Your estimate needs the base rate plus fringe, not just the base rate.
  • Labor burden: payroll taxes, workers’ compensation and insurance are usually calculated on the higher wages, so the burden goes up too.
  • Crew mix: apprentices can usually only be paid apprentice rates if they are in a registered program and within the allowed ratio. Helpers or trainees may not be listed at all.
  • Administration: weekly certified payroll, posters on site, and compliance reviews add office time that open shop jobs do not have.

How to build a prevailing wage MEP estimate

1. Find the correct wage determination

Check the specifications for the wage decision number, or look it up for the project’s county and construction type (building, heavy, highway or residential). Use the determination that is in effect for the bid, and watch for modifications issued before bid day.

2. Match each task to a classification

Electricians, plumbers and pipefitters, sheet metal workers, laborers, operators and low voltage technicians can all have different rates. Ductwork installed by sheet metal workers, piping by pipefitters and trenching by laborers or operators should each be priced at the correct classification. If a classification you need is missing, it must be requested through the contracting officer or the prime contractor.

3. Apply the rates to your labor hours

The quantity takeoff and labor hours do not change because a job is prevailing wage. What changes is the cost per hour. A good estimate keeps hours and rates separate, so you can price the same takeoff at open shop, union or prevailing wage rates and compare the results.

4. Add burden, overtime and compliance costs

Add payroll taxes and insurance on the higher wages, overtime at the required rate if the schedule calls for it, and the office time for certified payroll and compliance documents.

Common prevailing wage estimating mistakes

  1. Using your normal shop rates on a public job because the prevailing wage clause was buried in the specifications.
  2. Pricing only the base rate and forgetting the fringe benefits.
  3. Using the wrong county or construction type for the wage determination.
  4. Assuming you can use helpers or unregistered apprentices at lower rates.
  5. Pricing all trade work at one classification instead of matching each task to its own rate.
  6. Leaving out certified payroll and compliance administration.

Prevailing wage estimating FAQ

Where do I find Davis-Bacon wage rates?

Federal Davis-Bacon wage determinations are published on SAM.gov. Search by state, county and construction type, or use the wage decision number listed in the project specifications. State prevailing wage rates are published by each state’s labor department.

What is certified payroll?

Certified payroll is a weekly payroll report, often on form WH-347 or a state form, that shows each worker’s classification, hours, rates and fringe benefits, with a signed statement of compliance. It is required on most prevailing wage projects.

Is prevailing wage the same as union wages?

Not always. In some areas the prevailing rate is based on union agreements, and in others it is not. Always use the rates in the wage determination for the project, whether your company is union or open shop.

Get a prevailing wage MEP estimate

MEP Estimation Services prepares takeoffs and estimates for public and private projects across the United States, with labor hours shown separately so they can be priced at open shop, union or prevailing wage rates. We cover electrical, plumbing and mechanical and HVAC work, with color-coded marked-up drawings and an Excel file, usually within 24-48 hours. Bidding a public healthcare job? See our healthcare MEP estimating guide, or explore our full MEP estimating services.

Send your plans for a free quote.